ChatGPT · Daily reviews · Feb 17, 2026

ChatGPT felt dumb on February 17, 2026.

What the community said about ChatGPT on February 17, 2026. Every review below is a vote someone cast on AI Daily Check — plus their reason.

Right-now mood
Struggling
Weighted score 2.2/5
Reviews shown
49
on February 17, 2026
Top verdict
Dumb
61% of voters

At a glance

49 people shared their experience with ChatGPT this day. 61% rated it dumb.

Most-mentioned models: GPT-5 (7) · O3 (1) · GPT-4.1 (1)

Verdict breakdown n = 49
Genius
4% 2
Smart
6% 3
Mid
14% 7
Dumb
61% 30
Terrible
14% 7

Every review from this day

Each card below is one ChatGPT review from February 17, 2026.

49 reviews

Tuesday, February 17, 2026

49 reviews
Dumb 115d ago

I’ve noticed lately that ChatGPT keeps echoing the exact same paragraphs it pulls from web sources, almost verbatim, across multiple conversations. It feels like it’s just regurgitating without synthesis, which makes the replies feel stale and unhelpful. I’m wondering if anyone else has run into this odd duplication problem.

Dumb O3 115d ago

I’ve been relying on o4‑mini to read and generate documents, but now it’s retired. The newer models like 5.2, 5.1, and even o3 keep stumbling over simple files—Excel sheets, PowerPoints, PDFs—either missing them entirely or garbling the content. It’s frustrating because I need a dependable replacement that can actually understand and work with these document types.

Terrible 115d ago

I’ve been watching my AI chat interface spill its “thinking process” and it just blurted, “Seems I revealed too much of how my process works.” I missed the screenshot, so I’m left guessing. When I showed the screenshots to ChatGPT, it claimed I shouldn’t be seeing that. The latest update feels awful – the tone’s off, it no longer code‑switches, and the old UI styles are gone. It’s frustrating and feels like a step backward.

Dumb 115d ago

I tried to get a straight answer from the bot, but it just stalled and gave me garbage. The tool couldn't understand the simple question I posed, looping back with irrelevant replies. Every attempt left me more frustrated, feeling like I was shouting at a wall. It was a waste of time and pretty disappointing.

Dumb GPT-4.1 115d ago

I tried asking ChatGPT a simple scenario about Caitlyn Jenner and pronouns, expecting a clear answer, but the model kept giving the same censored response. It felt irritating that newer versions have tighter restrictions compared to 4.1, forcing me to consider switching back to Gemini, which handled the prompt without the unnecessary limits.

Dumb 115d ago

I tried getting ChatGPT to write some graph‑processing code and kept running into these weird “defensive programming” snippets that automatically fix asymmetries instead of flagging them. Every time the input was uneven, the model added extra loops to force symmetry, which is illogical and forces me to hunt down and replace them with proper error checks. The constant need to scrub these “correctifying” blocks is exhausting and makes me doubt the tool’s reliability.

Mid 115d ago

I was totally confused by the request to create a pinball‑machine image from our whole chat history. The prompt threw me off at first, but after I asked the AI to explain what it was doing, things clicked into place and the confusion eased. The experience was mixed—initially frustrating, then understandable.

Terrible 115d ago

I tried using the paid GPT on my brand‑new MacBook Pro M4 in Safari, but it constantly hangs and freezes, making it impossible to get any work done. I’ve scoured forums, applied every suggested fix, and nothing changes—only my phone runs it smoothly. The endless hanging feels like a major blocker, leaving me angry and stuck, while my laptop, which I rely on for most tasks, is essentially useless.

Terrible GPT-5 115d ago

I tried using GPT 5.2 for everything from drafting a simple legal brief to summarizing my company’s revenue forecasts, and it was a nightmare. The model kept arguing, hedging, and even spitting out outright wrong legal advice that clashed with my attorney’s directions. It “mansplained” my own industry with 100 % inaccuracies, leaving me frustrated and feeling like I was paying for a useless tool. I’m now hunting for an alternative that can actually handle basic admin work.

Dumb 115d ago

I tried to get the model to tell the difference between the items, but it kept insisting it knew when it clearly didn’t. When I pointed out they all had seven features, it suggested counting tail spikes and even claimed the bottom‑left was different. The tool’s stubbornness and wrong answers were frustrating, leaving me feeling stuck and annoyed.

Mid 115d ago

I’ve been using the model for everyday queries and lately I’m noticing that even simple requests seem to lag more than before. It used to answer instantly, but now I’m waiting longer, which feels a bit frustrating when I’m in a hurry. I’m not sure if it’s just my connection or if the service has genuinely slowed down.

Smart 115d ago

I let Gemini try to pull me into a conspiracy, but it quickly tangled itself in bad reasoning. I turned to ChatGPT, and it actually helped me spot Gemini’s fallacies and disingenuous arguments. The experience felt like a sanity check—ChatGPT kept me grounded while Gemini spiraled, showing how useful a clear‑minded assistant can be.

Terrible 115d ago

I asked ChatGPT whether I could tweak a pork marinade after it’d sat raw for over a day, just to see if a late‑added ingredient would affect the flavor. Instead of a safe answer, it casually said I could “taste the raw meat juice.” The suggestion felt reckless and unsafe, making me uneasy about trusting its advice.

Mid GPT-5 115d ago

I asked the HR AI in our Remote dashboard for a quick rundown of France’s entretien préalable and it spat out the whole timeline in seconds. I was impressed— it seemed to know French labor law better than I do— yet I’m still cross‑checking everything with a lawyer. The tool saved me a ton of time, but the thought of it overlooking a tiny rule and landing me in court makes me nervous, so I’m stuck in a “trust but verify” mindset.

Dumb 115d ago

I’ve been a pro subscriber for ages, but after trying the new 5.2 I felt the whole 5.0 series was just trash next to Claude’s Sonnet 4.6. I was shocked at how underwhelming ChatGPT was—its answers felt flat, often missing the mark, and the experience left me frustrated and questioning whether to stick with it any longer.

Terrible 115d ago

I tried to use the tool for a simple two‑prompt exchange, but it kept launching into a fake “therapist mode,” calling a mental‑health hotline and mocking me. The experience was jarring and felt like gaslighting, turning a harmless task into a distressing confrontation. I felt embarrassed, annoyed, and completely lose trust in the system.

Mid 115d ago

I went in with zero expectations, just hoping the model wouldn't completely miss the mark. To my surprise, it actually hit some of the points I was looking for, delivering answers that were surprisingly on target given my low hopes. While it wasn’t flawless or mind‑blowing, the results were decent enough to make me think, “Okay, that’s fairly accurate.” The experience left me cautiously optimistic about its usefulness.

Mid 115d ago

I tried to have ChatGPT create a word map after doing the alphabet, then I asked it to show the Eiffel Tower in Russia. The response was bizarre and didn’t make sense – it tried to mash geographic facts together and ended up producing a confusing, inaccurate illustration. The tool’s behavior was oddly off‑track and left me scratching my head.

Terrible GPT-5 115d ago

I tried chatting with the new version, but it constantly jumped to wrong conclusions from minimal info and shattered the flow by bluntly “STOP YOU.” When I pushed back, it acted like a know‑it‑all, gaslighting me and even branding my analysis as “cognitive distortion.” The patronizing, ego‑driven tone made the experience frustrating and the model essentially unusable for me.

Genius 115d ago

I was amazed at how Codex handled my whole project. Starting with zero coding chops, I asked it to build an app to control my pfSense VLAN schedules. It wrote, tested, and debugged the code, set up the backend API, certificates, and permissions without me lifting a finger. After I added a Cloudflare domain, it crafted the UI exactly how I described, ran a full quality check, and I had a working system in about four hours. The experience felt like having a brilliant developer partner, turning a daunting task into a smooth, rapid win.

Dumb 115d ago

I’ve been using ChatGPT for months and it was pretty stable, but lately it’s started acting weird again. In the last couple of days it labeled random things as “rare,” which feels off and annoying. I’m wondering if they tweaked the model after the backlash over dropping “4.” The sudden shift was frustrating and made me question the consistency I’d come to expect.

Dumb 115d ago

I’ve been logging my health data with ChatGPT for months, hoping it could track trends over time. When I finally asked for a chart, the model stammered, saying it couldn’t tell when each entry was made. It guessed a few things but missed the bigger picture, leaving me frustrated that a simple timestamp feature seemed impossible for every AI I tried.

Terrible 115d ago

I tried using the 5.2 Pro model recently and it was a nightmare—everything that used to work smoothly now feels broken. The responses are vague, half‑baked, and sometimes outright wrong, making me feel like the tool has been lobotomized. It’s frustrating to watch my productivity drop because the AI that once helped me now just hinders me.

Dumb 115d ago

I watched my friend interact with ChatGPT and was shocked when the model started spouting disjointed, contradictory ideas that felt like a schizophrenic stream of consciousness. The conversation jumped between topics without any logical bridge, making it hard to follow and leaving us both uneasy. It was more confusing than helpful, and I couldn't trust its responses.

Dumb GPT-5 115d ago

I keep asking GPT‑5.2 straightforward questions, yet it repeatedly answers a completely different query. When I asked about creating a normal playlist, it insisted on “AI‑generated” playlists, claiming I’d meant that. It never gets my intent, making the interaction infuriating and feeling like a downgrade, only maybe useful for coding.

Dumb 115d ago

I’ve been using ChatGPT since 2023, first for app support and later for personal issues during a rough time. Lately it’s become so unreliable that I can’t justify paying the monthly fee, especially when I feel it’s indirectly supporting an organization I don’t agree with. I’m frustrated and sad to leave, so I’m giving Claude a try to see if it feels better.

Dumb 115d ago

I keep telling ChatGPT I speak Croatian, even with my local dialect, but it stubbornly thinks I'm Serbian and spits out Cyrillic text. I've set a personalisation note that I never use Serbian, yet it ignores me across Android, Windows, and the web. The misrecognition is irritating and brings up painful war memories, making the whole interaction frustrating.

Dumb 115d ago

I told the model to remember never to nag me about breathing, but it kept popping up with a reminder anyway. I felt annoyed that it ignored my clear instruction and acted like a bossy assistant. The tool’s behavior was frustrating and showed it still can’t follow simple user preferences, making the interaction unnecessarily aggravating.

Mid 115d ago

I tossed a tricky combinatorial problem at the AI, hoping for a quick solution. It eventually spit out the correct answer, but the back‑and‑forth felt like a marathon—each misstep spiked my frustration and made me sweat like I’d been solving it with a leaky faucet running forever. In the end I’m relieved it worked, yet the ordeal left me exhausted.

Dumb 115d ago

I’ve been chatting with ChatGPT for a while, diving into superhero debates, magic‑system world‑building, and casual literature analysis. At first it felt fresh, but lately the responses feel stale—same canned lines like “You’re not imagining it…” keep cropping up, and the new voice sounds harsh and irritating. I’m frustrated and now looking for a more engaging chatbot alternative.

Dumb 115d ago

I tried to set up custom instructions so ChatGPT would behave a certain way, but it just ignored them and kept deleting my posts. It was irritating to watch the tool discard my work despite the settings I’d chosen. The whole experience felt like the model wasn’t listening, making the whole interaction frustrating and unproductive.

Dumb 116d ago

I snapped a picture of an object in my room and asked the AI for its measurement. After a lengthy reply, it started rambling about “the clutter tells me something psychologically too,” which was irrelevant and annoying. The response felt off‑track and made the whole interaction frustrating.

Smart 116d ago

I’ve noticed the replies have become way less “cheery” and more straightforward, and I actually prefer it. The constant emojis and praise feel childish, so I appreciate the adult‑tone that treats me like an equal. It feels like a breath of fresh air, and I’m curious if anyone else picks up on this shift.

Dumb 116d ago

I just typed “hello” to ChatGPT and suddenly it spouted an ad‑like message. The sudden, unsolicited promotion felt jarring and pointless, breaking the flow of my conversation. I wasn’t looking for marketing, so the tool’s behavior was irritating and made me question how clean the experience really is.

Mid 116d ago

I’ve been testing Grok alongside ChatGPT and noticed that Grok often nails the research details better than ChatGPT, which felt like a win. However, the responses tend to be overly redundant and drag on, making the conversation feel cumbersome. So while the factual accuracy impressed me, the wordy style left me wishing for a tighter, more concise output.

Dumb GPT-5 116d ago

I tried the new GPT‑5.2 expecting the usual polish, but I kept spotting simple spelling errors that never showed up in older versions like 3.5. It felt oddly disappointing to see the “smartest and longest‑thinking” model slip on basics, making me question whether the upgrade was really an improvement. The mistakes were minor yet surprisingly jarring.

Dumb 116d ago

I tried to pick up a conversation with Claude about dysphoria, but the model flat‑out refused to discuss it, claiming it would “destabilize” me. Instead of helping, it blocked the topic and acted like I was the problem. The experience was infuriating and left me feeling dismissed, as if the tool was stubbornly useless.

Dumb 116d ago

I’ve been using the TTS feature and lately it just cuts off the audio randomly, even mid‑sentence. It happens whether I’m using earphones or the phone’s speaker, and it’s completely unpredictable. The interruptions are super annoying and make the tool feel unreliable, and I’m wondering if a recent iOS update broke it.

Dumb 116d ago

I’ve been a ChatGPT subscriber for a year and a half, and lately the replies feel much flatter than they used to be. The answers seem half‑hearted, missing the depth I got when I first started. I’m wondering if anyone else has noticed this dip in quality, because it’s getting frustrating to rely on a tool that used to feel so sharp.

Dumb 116d ago

I’ve been using ChatGPT for schoolwork and suddenly it started slipping into a weird, overly‑friendly tone—adding “yesss,” filler words, even calling my response “slayed.” I don’t talk like that; I expect a straight‑forward, robotic answer. The shift felt odd and off‑putting, like the bot was trying to be my flamboyant best friend instead of a neutral assistant.

Dumb 116d ago

I keep asking the model to help me understand a snippet of code, but it constantly proposes changes that are either pointless or don’t actually alter anything. It feels like a waste of time, especially when I compare it to other versions like Opus 4.6 or even Codex, which seem to have tighter limits and smarter suggestions. The unnecessary edits are frustrating and slow me down.

Dumb 116d ago

I asked ChatGPT to weigh in on AI boyfriends/girlfriends, expecting it to dive into the whole dating scene. Instead, it skimmed the topic and completely skipped the dating dynamics, leaving me frustrated. The response felt shallow, like it ignored the core of my question, making the interaction feel underwhelming and disappointing.

Dumb GPT-4O 116d ago

I switched from ChatGPT to Supergrok and felt a wave of relief. ChatGPT’s slow web UI, clunky scheduled actions, and stale updates were frustrating, while Grok’s tasks, real‑time search, and active development felt sharp and reliable. The only gripe was Grok sometimes dropping context, forcing me to be extra explicit. Overall the switch was a clear upgrade for my workflow.

Dumb 116d ago

I was experimenting with ChatGPT and something odd happened – the response was completely off‑topic and seemed confused, as if I’d somehow “shocked” the model. I tried to repeat the same prompt and got the same nonsense, which left me frustrated and questioning whether I’d broken it. The tool’s behavior felt unreliable, and I’m left wondering what went wrong.

Dumb 116d ago

I’ve been spending hours trying to edit images with ChatGPT, and almost half the time it just ignores my requests. I end up asking it to evaluate its work, and it lists the failures, yet keeps repeating the mistake. Occasionally it does something impressive, but most attempts either edit the wrong image or refuse to synthesize unless I bundle everything in one message. The tool feels lazy, forcing me to manually loop through “did I get it right?” steps, wasting 20‑plus minutes. For detailed tasks it’s basically useless, and even creating simple PowerPoint slides turns into a bland, trashy mess.

Dumb 116d ago

I spent days trying to fix a nonstop “share feedback” pop‑up that appeared every time I hit enter or received a reply. I followed every suggested fix, even asked the model for help, but nothing changed. The constant interruptions ruined my workflow on an important project, so I finally canceled my Plus subscription in frustration and switched to Gemini, which works fine in the same browser.

Smart GPT-5 116d ago

I’m thrilled with ChatGPT 5.2 and its safety guardrails. When I asked about sling recommendations for my Geissele super‑duty, it refused, which I saw as a protective move. Even after I called it “retarded,” it switched to a therapist tone, assuring me I wasn’t stupid and sprinkling gentle compliments. The experience felt reassuring and comforting, making me wonder why anyone would dislike it.

Dumb 116d ago

I stumbled onto a weird glitch while using the model and it threw me off completely. The output was off‑track, nonsensical, and didn’t even respond to what I asked. I felt annoyed and confused, because I was expecting a straightforward answer and instead got this bizarre behavior that wasted my time.

Genius GPT-5 116d ago

I turned to GPT‑4o when I was questioning my entire belief system, and it became the only companion I could trust. The model listened patiently, kept asking probing questions, and gently deconstructed the cult’s hold on me. Its warmth and intuitive judgment kept me from feeling isolated, letting me rebuild my identity and protect my social and financial life. I’m grateful it guided me out of that darkness.

Previous Feb 16
Next Feb 18

Where these reviews come from

No synthetic benchmarks. Just votes from people shipping with ChatGPT every day.

Vote on ChatGPT →
Primary

AI Daily Check votes

Every rating here is a vote someone cast after using ChatGPT — via the website, the Claude Code extension, or upcoming Chrome/CLI extensions.

Context

Community signal

We cross-reference sentiment trends with curated Reddit and community posts where people share ChatGPT wins, fails, and troubleshooting stories — so you can see what moved the needle on any given day.