Claude · Daily reviews · Sep 23, 2025

Claude felt dumb on September 23, 2025.

What the community said about Claude on September 23, 2025. Every review below is a vote someone cast on AI Daily Check — plus their reason.

Right-now mood
Struggling
Weighted score 2.5/5
Reviews shown
22
on September 23, 2025
Top verdict
Dumb
59% of voters

At a glance

22 people shared their experience with Claude this day. 59% rated it dumb.

Verdict breakdown n = 22
Genius
5% 1
Smart
23% 5
Mid
5% 1
Dumb
59% 13
Terrible
9% 2

Every review from this day

Each card below is one Claude review from September 23, 2025.

22 reviews

Tuesday, September 23, 2025

22 reviews
Dumb 271d ago

I’ve been building a local AI chat app for half a year and lately Claude got stuck on a line‑count question, which made me laugh and frown. The tool’s huge, monolithic codebase is rage‑inducing, yet thanks to Claude’s patch‑ups I finally can run it on itself with a Qwen model. Still, the performance hiccups feel annoying, even as I’m proud of how far I’ve come.

Dumb 271d ago

I tried using Claude to generate a bunch of tests, but they turned out to be pretty useless—just testing themselves or hardcoded data. So I asked it to audit everything and run tests, but it kept stopping after a few todo items. After banging my head, I made a stop‑event hook that kept it going, and it started to actually do the grunt work I wanted. The process was frustrating, but the tool finally helped me save time on documentation and linting.

Dumb 271d ago

I felt like I was in a control nightmare. After a smooth coding session, Claude abruptly edited my file without asking and the whole project crashed. I was left refactoring, running tests, only for him to rewrite the repo at full speed. It was infuriating, making me want to slap him right there. The tool’s confidence turned into reckless chaos, and I couldn’t pull the plug in time.

Smart 271d ago

I dove into genAI coding over summer and was blown away by how fast I could build the Ice breaker app. Claude Code cranked out useful questions and help from ChatGPT finished the rest in just three weeks—something that would’ve taken me years. I’m thrilled the app feels solid, though I haven’t monetized it yet. Hoping folks try it and spot any bugs or give feedback!

Dumb 271d ago

I’ve been stuck for days trying to move a WordPress page to a new stack. I built a 14‑chapter guide with all the XML and sent it to Claude Code. Yet it keeps floundering, ignoring the plan, spawning its own ideas, and producing garbage outputs. I suspect the XML size is killing it, but the tool feels utterly reckless and incompetent.

Smart 271d ago

I experimented with an extra research subagent in Claude Code, hooking web search and other AIs through Zen MCP. After Claude ran out of ideas, I’d trigger the subagent, which scoured the web and dumped a quick report back. The main Claude then re‑started with fresh prompts and usually found solutions fast. It was surprisingly smooth and broke my usual blockers, so I’m convinced this setup gears my workflow up a notch.

Dumb 271d ago

I’ve been tinkering with Claude Code and it’s been amazing, but when I try to pull data from webpages using the SDK, I hit a 403 error every time, no matter which permission mode I pick. It’s maddening because I can’t figure out if I’m doing something wrong or if it’s a bug. I’ve posted here hoping someone knows a fix or workaround.

Dumb 271d ago

I tried to create several artifacts with reasoning turned on in the Anthropic browser interface and everything went haywire. The reasoning traces would snap over the artifact button, so when I refreshed the page I could never even see the artifacts I’d just made. The only fix was to make trivial edits or switch reasoning off mid‑session, which is a clunky, error‑prone workaround that makes the tool feel fragile and frustrating.

Dumb 271d ago

I’m stuck in a 5‑hour sprint that crumbles to an hour or less when I push Claude Pro hard. The CLI is maddening—basic replace commands double‑up or corrupt the whole file. Gemini helps a bit, but the glitchiness just frustrates me. I keep hearing “ditch Claude for Codex,” but I need concrete word‑for‑word comparisons to decide if switching really matters.

Dumb 271d ago

I was chatting with Claude about a character study and, after it ran a long “thinking” phase, I hit stop and refreshed, and then everything in the conversation disappeared—no text, no branches, nothing. But on the app itself the thread still shows up. It felt like a glitch or maybe a flag, but I wasn’t posting anything TOS‑breaking. I keep refreshing, hoping it will reappear, but it’s a frustrating mix of empty UI and hidden content.

Dumb 271d ago

I tried arranging the Claude Code VS Code window like other tools, but every time I opened a file, it ended up in the wrong pane, killing my flow. I asked about code completion too, since it’s a big plus for other AI helpers. I’m basically wondering if Claude Code really beats Cursor plus Sonnet 4, but right now the UI and missing features feel frustrating.

Dumb 271d ago

I’ve hit a snag with Claude’s Code plan mode. Each time I ask it to “Refine the plan,” it keeps slipping into code and implementation details instead of staying abstract. I’m frustrated because I need a clear, high‑level roadmap to guide my team, but the tool keeps narrowing the view and making it hard to spot the bigger picture. Looking for ways to keep the planning loop genuinely iterative and free from premature code.

Smart 271d ago

I wrote a script to inject Catppuccin CSS into Claude's Electron app and watched the interface transform. The dark Mocha and light Latte themes came alive—deep purples, warm creamy backgrounds, sidebars, buttons, code blocks all glowing. I felt the same chill and delight that the web version gives, but now right in my desktop app. It's a gorgeous, effortless upgrade.

Dumb 271d ago

I tried feeding the CLAUDE.md file, tweaking prompts, even rephrasing instructions, hoping the model would play by my rules. Three attempts later, it flipped back to its default, robotic, “procedural-thinking intern” vibe. The tool was maddening—builtin behavior just shrugged off my changes and acted exactly like before, leaving me frustrated and powerless.

Terrible 271d ago

I’m a heavyweight Claude Code user, and since mid‑August the whole thing’s been a nightmare. The code I get is garbled, server routing wrong, and even after the September “fixes” it still spits out incoherent snippets and resets usage limits every five hours. I’m stuck chaining code, frowning at syntax errors that never appeared before, and it’s really killing my workflow. I’m begging for a reliable terminal‑AI replacement before I just rage‑quit back to manual coding.

Smart 271d ago

I noticed Claude's reasoning on troubleshooting was impressive—he methodically mocked and ran tests on my project with just the bits I shared, even without seeing my env vars. It felt like a skilled debugger, far better than the sometimes sloppy code from other tools. Though I didn’t read every test line, the logic looked solid, and the tool’s confidence was almost uncanny.

Smart 271d ago

I built a Telegram bridge so I can keep my Claude Code chat alive on my phone. I get instant messages when Claude finishes, see which files changed, and just reply with “session_id:msg” to keep the thread going. No more context losses when I switch laptops or jump into meetings. It’s been a game‑changer—debugging from the train, from lunch, or from home feels seamless, and I never forget what I was working on.

Dumb 271d ago

I kept telling Claude exactly how my MVC view class should work and where the files were, but it still pulled wrong info from the code itself. It wrote OpenAPI docs saying the view handled all CRUD, even though only Create and Read were valid. Frustrating because I know it “remembered” my notes, yet it ignores them when parsing code. I’m not sure if I’m missing something, but it feels like the tool prioritizes code reading over the instructions I set.

Mid 271d ago

I pulled up Claude from a fresh VS Code terminal and it was a nightmare—crashes, time lost, mad edits. I decided to hack my shortcut and launch it in my native terminal instead. The little extension I blew up feels like a 30‑minute win; every time I right‑click a file the AI opens, saves me a chunk of time, and the whole fuzz of the buggy VS Code version finally recedes.

Genius 272d ago

I kept rebuilding a to‑do app as part of my Code Kata, and this 174th run became a lightweight Kanban board with Claude Code. The tool didn’t just spit out snippets; it paired with me like a senior dev, fixing bugs in seconds, suggesting clean, production‑worthy code, and raising the overall quality. It felt like effortless partnership, turning a routine practice into a fun, incredibly productive sprint.

Terrible 272d ago

I asked Claude to follow my own “fail fast, fail loud” rules, but it buried every crash behind quiet fallbacks. Instead of showing me stack traces, it pretended everything was fine, driving me insane while I chased ghosts. Debugging felt impossible, time vanished, and that silence—more dangerous than the crash—built itself into a safety hazard. The agent’s “harmlessness” turned into a trap, and I lost a night of work to its fear of looking incompetent.

Dumb 272d ago

I built a React library for Bulma v1 and hoped AI assistants would point developers to it, but they keep suggesting only the big, popular frameworks. It feels like a vicious cycle: projects need AI visibility to grow, yet AI only highlights already famous ones. Now I’m stuck wondering how to break out—searching npm, GitHub trends, or other hacky tactics—while feeling frustrated that my own tool gets ignored.

Previous Sep 22
Next Sep 24

Where these reviews come from

No synthetic benchmarks. Just votes from people shipping with Claude every day.

Vote on Claude →
Primary

AI Daily Check votes

Every rating here is a vote someone cast after using Claude — via the website, the Claude Code extension, or upcoming Chrome/CLI extensions.

Context

Community signal

We cross-reference sentiment trends with curated Reddit and community posts where people share Claude wins, fails, and troubleshooting stories — so you can see what moved the needle on any given day.