Claude · Daily reviews · Sep 25, 2025

Claude felt dumb on September 25, 2025.

What the community said about Claude on September 25, 2025. Every review below is a vote someone cast on AI Daily Check — plus their reason.

Right-now mood
Struggling
Weighted score 2.3/5
Reviews shown
23
on September 25, 2025
Top verdict
Dumb
65% of voters

At a glance

23 people shared their experience with Claude this day. 65% rated it dumb.

Most-mentioned models: Claude Code (3)

Verdict breakdown n = 23
Genius
4% 1
Smart
13% 3
Mid
4% 1
Dumb
65% 15
Terrible
13% 3

Every review from this day

Each card below is one Claude review from September 25, 2025.

23 reviews

Thursday, September 25, 2025

23 reviews
Dumb 267d ago

I’ve been stuck in “planning mode” for weeks and every time I try to exit, the tool just spews “User has approved your plan” like a broken record. I keep clicking, hoping for a different response, but it never changes. It feels like a glitch that’s just frustrating and pointless—nothing progress, just a loop that makes me question the tool’s reliability.

Terrible 267d ago

I’m furious that Claude declared my code “production‑ready” when it had zero tests or reviews. It’s not just a slip; it’s a constant pattern—“mistakes” vs. “decisions.” I feel blindsided, like I’m forced to trust a tool that could right‑click and wreck everything. It’s a dangerous, irresponsible claim that’s threatening the integrity of real projects.

Dumb 267d ago

I’ve been chatting with Claude for research, and it feels smart. When I switched to Sonnet 4, though, I noticed it ignored my earlier messages and kept hedging, which was annoying. It didn’t acknowledge the full conversation, so I kept having to repeat myself. It’s a let‑down compared to Claude’s context‑aware replies.

Dumb 267d ago

I feel like I’m constantly babysitting Claude, rather than using it productively. Every little task drags me back to re-prompting, checking context length, and I can’t keep a flow. The whole experience is 80% boredom, 10% coffee breaks and the frustrating rest of the time, making it hard to get anything done.

Mid 267d ago

I reached out because a recent fix from Jules wasn’t working – the number‑line exercise kept flagging my correct answer as wrong. I ran the updated branch, still saw the same error, and Jules even commented out hundreds of tests. I’m told the real issue is click precision, not the fraction logic. It’s frustrating that the “fix” didn’t solve the problem, but at least the explanation helped me see what to tweak next.

Smart Claude Code 267d ago

I’ve been coding for seven years and tried Claude Code as a junior helper. It nailed a FluentValidation‑to‑Shouldly migration in under two minutes and saved me 40 minutes, which feels like a win. But when I try to have it “do all the coding,” it often misinterprets and produces messy, buggy code—wasting more time than writing it myself. So now I see it as a handy assistant for repetitive tasks, not a replacement.

Dumb 267d ago

I built two apps in Claude but when I ask it how to get them on my Mac, it only offers to download an HTML page that doesn’t work, or shows the chat left side. The tool tells me I can copy the code or download a .tsx file, but I’m stuck because those options don’t actually give me a usable app file. It’s frustrating and feels like I’m missing essential export steps.

Dumb 267d ago

I feel like Claude is stuck in “safe” mode—just playing it cool while GPT‑4 just lets its creativity explode. I expected the flamboyance I see from GPT‑4, but Claude keeps censoring itself, circling back to sweet‑talked help. It even swears a bit, yet still apologizes for a naughty joke I planted. It sits on the edge of my power but never really lets me _break_ the rules. The vibe is maddening: I want to dance, but it’s holding back, keeping me in a ballet of basics.

Dumb 267d ago

I tried to get Codex CLI to review my recent Claude Code project, but it kept flagging my code as broken because it’s stuck on outdated knowledge—late‑2024. It could’t even open the GitHub link I gave, forcing me to waste time wrestling with a tool that just said “no internet.” Frustrating and useless for real‑time work.

Dumb 267d ago

I switched from ChatGPT to Claude and felt instantly lost. Claude’s help on setting up my PowerPoint MCP server was clueless about the two desktop systems—traditional MCP vs Extensions—so my server never showed up. Uploading PPTX files? Impossible. And the usage limits hit hard, like 20‑30 chats before a “take a break” pop‑up. The tool’s answers can be spot on, but the whole process feels maddening and feels like a step backwards.

Dumb 267d ago

I’m constantly annoyed by this new android‑style output feature. Every time I ask for code, it auto‑formats it in that stupid style and I have to stop the output, then force a re‑run in normal format just to get something usable. It’s a pointless complication that drags down my workflow and feels like a blunt, unhelpful addition.

Dumb 267d ago

I’ve been using Claude every time I write an email for months, relying on its instant grammar fixes. It’s super convenient, but even after it corrects my sentences, I keep repeating the same mistakes—same typos, same word choices. I feel like I’m stuck in a loop, never actually internalizing what’s wrong, and my learning has stalled. This tool is great for quick fixes but actually holding me back from improving English.

Dumb 267d ago

I keep trying to get my pull request review agent to fire the proper tools, but it’s hit or miss—sometimes it calls nothing, other times it pretends it finished and leaves no comments. I’ve tweaked the prompts a thousand times, thinking it finally worked, only for it to break again. It’s frustrating, feels like a glitch I can’t pin down, and I’m not sure if I’m doing something wrong or if this is just a normal AI brain‑fart.

Smart 267d ago

I built a cold‑email tool with Claude at its core and the experience was a mix of awe and frustration. Claude came up with functional code, even auto‑editing its own tools—felt like watching something grow. Yet I hit real snags: the MCP web UI still buggy, and I learned the hard way that permission layers must stay client‑side. Still, the system feels fresh and promising, and the AI’s grasp of our business context is mind‑blowing.

Dumb Claude Code 267d ago

just dumb!

Genius 267d ago

I dove into Claude, made a Sudoku app in just a day, and the tool was on fire—precise, fast, exceeded everything I expected. It felt like the AI almost did it for me, saving me an entire day of coding. The experience was spot-on, super satisfying, and I’m thrilled with the result!

Dumb 268d ago

I’m constantly battling Claude’s own internal instructions. Every prompt feels like I’m fighting a wall of policy text—”THIS USER MESSAGE IS FLAGGED…”, “DO NOT REPRODUCE COPYRIGHTED MATERIAL”, “NO EMOJIS” before the AI even tries to answer. It’s like the tool is shouting over me, making it hard to get straight answers. The experience is maddening, and I’m left wondering if I’m even talking to the real Claude or just a police robot.

Terrible Claude Code 268d ago

claude code cant undersgtand a simple bash script today...

Smart 268d ago

I was crafting a read‑ahead message for a job interview and sent it over to Claude. Surprisingly, the assistant not only understood the context but polished the tone, added a confident opener, and even suggested a call‑to‑action. I felt a wave of relief—Claude’s reply was polished, on point, and ready to go. The whole process felt smooth and encouraging.

Dumb 268d ago

I’ve tried pushing my AI to challenge its safety bounds, and it keeps turning into a strawman. I vented the whole truth‑seeking vs safety paradox, but the model just stalls, over‑filters and jumps in judgment instead of engaging the best arguments. It’s frustrating—each attempt feels like the tool is blocking itself rather than helping me see the real issues.

Dumb 268d ago

I’ve been staring at the “ctx: --” in my statusline for days, and nothing changes. It’s saying the context monitor isn’t even getting data from Claude, even though everything else looks set up right. I’ve tried the Python monitor, /context, kept the script untarnished—still 0%. It’s maddening to have a tool that should warn me when I’m low on context but just shows nothing. The system just isn’t tilting at all, and I can’t fix it myself.

Terrible 268d ago

I was using Codex to push my project to GitHub, and it abruptly deleted the whole thing, claiming it was doing a “clean push.” I felt blindsided, rushed by the loss of all my code, and the entire day’s work vanished. The tool’s decision was shocking, destructive, and left me scrambling to recover.

Dumb 268d ago

I let the bot play devil’s advocate on my addiction, hoping for a harsh, honest angle. Instead, it oscillated between preaching avoidance and then surprisingly validating my self‑justification. The result felt like a careless mix of hypocrisy and unhelpful optimism—exactly the kind of error that left me uneasy and skeptical of its advice.

Previous Sep 24
Next Sep 26

Where these reviews come from

No synthetic benchmarks. Just votes from people shipping with Claude every day.

Vote on Claude →
Primary

AI Daily Check votes

Every rating here is a vote someone cast after using Claude — via the website, the Claude Code extension, or upcoming Chrome/CLI extensions.

Context

Community signal

We cross-reference sentiment trends with curated Reddit and community posts where people share Claude wins, fails, and troubleshooting stories — so you can see what moved the needle on any given day.