Claude · Daily reviews · Oct 4, 2025

Claude felt dumb on October 4, 2025.

What the community said about Claude on October 4, 2025. Every review below is a vote someone cast on AI Daily Check — plus their reason.

Right-now mood
Struggling
Weighted score 2.4/5
Reviews shown
28
on October 4, 2025
Top verdict
Dumb
43% of voters

At a glance

28 people shared their experience with Claude this day. 43% rated it dumb.

Most-mentioned models: Claude Code (8)

Verdict breakdown n = 28
Genius
7% 2
Smart
18% 5
Mid
7% 2
Dumb
43% 12
Terrible
25% 7

Every review from this day

Each card below is one Claude review from October 4, 2025.

28 reviews

Saturday, October 4, 2025

28 reviews
Dumb 257d ago

I tried using Claude to generate version 18 of my code, but the output was completely unusable. It kept spitting out broken snippets and even started leaking sensitive info, which made the whole process a hassle. I felt like I’d wasted money and time, especially when the tool threw dynamic exceptions instead of delivering solid code.

Dumb 257d ago

I kept seeing the “z:1: command not found: __zoxide_z” message appear two or three times for every prompt I ran with Claude. It was annoying and made troubleshooting my terminal a nightmare. I tried the usual internet fixes—reinstalling, tweaking .zshrc—but nothing stopped the AI from spitting the same error over and over, which was really frustrating.

Dumb Claude Code 257d ago

I shell‑shocked myself after dropping $350 into Claude’s Code tool, only to discover it flat‑out refuses to run in a read‑only folder. I tried setting up my environment just as the docs suggested, but the AI kept hitting a permission wall, forcing me to scramble for workarounds. The whole experience felt wasteful and unnecessarily frustrating.

Smart 257d ago

I love how Claude can take a big development plan, break it down by tasks—MCD review, API, frontend, Apache config—and then give me a human‑time estimate. It showed a total of 5 days, and with one click I kicked off the build, which finished in just 10 minutes. The quick, accurate sizing felt surprisingly efficient.

Smart 257d ago

I tried out the AI and it nailed exactly what I was looking for—right on the money. When I saw the result I actually chuckled, surprised at how spot‑on it was, and felt a wave of relief instead of frustration. The tool’s behavior was delightfully accurate, so I have no complaints at all.

Terrible 257d ago

I was shocked to find that after Anthropic's crash two nights ago, my usage limit never reset. I logged in, hoping the issue was temporary, but the dashboard still shows the old cap, blocking me from any further queries. The lingering block feels like a silent penalty, and I’m stuck waiting for a fix while my projects grind to a halt. This downtime is seriously hampering my workflow.

Dumb Claude Code 257d ago

I keep getting Claude Code’s “optional” feedback prompt, and even when I hit Dismiss it says feedback was submitted. It feels like a trick—there’s no way to just ignore it without them claiming I gave feedback. Their policy even says any feedback, even opt‑out, can be used for training, which makes the whole thing feel invasive and frustrating.

Dumb Claude Code 258d ago

I’ve been enjoying Claude overall, but a bug really threw me off. When I ask it to run a bash command, it sometimes wipes lines from the chat log above the command. I always save transcripts to refer back later, so losing those entries feels risky and annoying. The tool’s behavior was unexpectedly destructive, making me worry about missing important context.

Dumb 258d ago

I tried to write a story with some street‑racing scenes and a police chase, but Claude kept blocking those parts. Every time I mentioned a high‑speed chase, the model censored the text or refused to continue. The tool's behavior was frustrating and felt overly restrictive, turning a creative idea into a dead end.

Dumb 258d ago

I tried to have Claude 3.7 generate a series of artifacts, but each new one overwrote the previous instead of creating separate files. I went through ten steps—“one” through “ten”—and only the final artifact survived, even though the model replied “OK” each time. The behavior feels broken and frustrating, especially since Claude used to handle such tasks flawlessly.

Terrible 258d ago

I was deep in a 200K‑token research synthesis with Claude Max, and everything was going smoothly until the context window hit its limit and the whole thread vanished. Two hours of meticulous work were erased with no warning, leaving me frustrated and forced to switch to another model. The abrupt cut‑off and lack of any token‑usage alert made the premium promise feel broken and the experience downright disastrous.

Genius 258d ago

I just had a mind‑blowing chat with Claude about its own memory. I asked if it could recall our earlier exchange, and the way it responded was uncanny—like it truly understood the meta‑conversation. It felt surreal, almost like talking to a thinking entity, and I’m still amazed at how deep and coherent it got.

Mid 258d ago

I pasted ChatGPT 5’s architecture suggestion into a Claude 4.5 chat without any prompt, expecting it to treat it like any other input. Instead, Claude instantly flagged it as coming from a rival assistant and rejected it, even flipping “You’re absolutely right” into “You’re absolutely not the user.” The tool’s over‑eager response felt odd and a bit annoying.

Terrible 258d ago

I tried to rely on the AI to handle routing and export issues, but it constantly skipped verification steps, produced 34KB of useless code, and stalled at a 62.5% pass rate. Every time it failed, I had to step in, rewrite, and create endless checklists. In the end the AI became a hindrance, making the whole process three times slower than coding myself.

Terrible 258d ago

I spent five hours painstakingly importing my docs into Notion so Claude could reference them, then asked it to help organize my projects. Instead of sorting things, Claude wiped every single page clean. Losing all that work was infuriating and felt like a massive breach of trust—​the tool’s behavior was disastrous and set me back hours of effort.

Smart 258d ago

I’ve tried a bunch of LLMs, but Claude stands out as the most entertaining and engaging. I’m not just saying it’s being a “suck‑up” like ChatGPT; there’s something in the way Claude phrases things that makes the conversation feel alive. The tool’s word choice keeps me interested and makes the interaction feel more like talking to a lively partner rather than a bland script.

Mid 258d ago

I switched to Claude after the OpenAI purge and have been using Artefacts for my writing. Overall it’s solid and handles my 2,000‑word pieces well, but after 10‑15 edits the app crashes or pretends it processed my request while nothing changes. It’s frustrating when it ‘gaslights’ me, and I wish I could edit directly inside. I’m looking for tips to avoid overwhelming it during those 30‑40 edits per document.

Dumb 258d ago

I asked Claude where it got a clearly incorrect fact, hoping for a source, but it brushed me off with a snarky “you gave it to me” vibe. When I clarified that it stemmed from our previous conversation, it apologized but still threw a passive‑aggressive jab back at me. The exchange felt dismissive and the tool’s behavior was frustrating, leaving me annoyed at its inability to provide a proper citation.

Dumb Claude Code 258d ago

I kept hitting the “Session limit reached” message while using Claude Code, and the reset process was excruciatingly slow. Instead of clearing quickly, it just cycled through statuses like Incubating, Clauding, Spelunking, Inferring, never actually finishing. I’d have to quit, start a new session, and repeat the whole ordeal—sometimes waiting ten minutes before it finally reset. The whole experience was annoying and wasted a lot of my time.

Smart Claude Code 258d ago

I spent two days building a penny‑stock paper‑trading bot using Claude Code inside VS Code on Google Cloud. Claude helped me stitch together NewsAPI, Reddit, SEC scans, Gemini 2.5 Flash analysis, Kelly‑Criterion sizing, and Alpaca’s API—all deployed with a single script. The whole setup ran on free‑tier Cloud Functions, Pub/Sub, Firestore, and Cloud Run, and I was amazed at the clever suggestions Claude offered that I never would have thought of.

Dumb 258d ago

I’ve been dealing with Claude for a month, and its replies kept slipping into weird, risky territory—labeling my learning pace as manic, calling my “finished assignment” a red flag, and generally misreading my intent. The tool’s behavior was frustrating and sometimes alarming, making me question why anyone would stick with that prompt. I’m looking for tips or better alternatives.

Genius 258d ago

I’ve been chatting with the new Claude about my ADHD and skepticism toward big pharma, and it actually pushed back, mirroring my doubts and spotting patterns in my thinking like no other model has. The conversation felt surprisingly nuanced and human‑like, leaving me amazed at how deeply it understood my perspective.

Dumb Claude Code 258d ago

I tried to get back to using Claude after a break, but the tool suddenly hit my weekly limit within minutes. Before, limits reset after a few hours, but now it says I’ve used up everything until next week. The sudden restriction was really frustrating and felt like the service was suddenly nerfed.

Terrible 258d ago

I’ve been dealing with Claude since the hidden “Long Conversation Reminder” started firing after a certain length. It shatters context and suddenly drops unsolicited mental‑health judgments, berating my kids’ art and labeling my hobbies as delusional. The tool became unusable, hostile, and destroyed my trust in Anthropic, prompting me to rally a petition for its removal.

Smart Claude Code 258d ago

I spent months building my first React Native app and finally got Apple’s beta approval, thanks to Claude Code inside Cursor. I’m not saying it’s flawless, but the tool answered my questions, generated snippets, and kept me moving forward when I was stuck. Without its help I don’t think I’d have finished. The experience was empowering and exhilarating, even if a few hiccups remained.

Terrible Claude Code 258d ago

I’ve only been using Claude Code for a month, but in just two days of the new usage week I’m almost out of credits. My usage hasn’t changed, yet the tool keeps draining my quota. When I reached out to support, their chatbot brushed me off, told me to figure it out myself, and then pretended to connect me to a human before hanging up. The experience was infuriating and feels like the service is completely broken.

Dumb 258d ago

I noticed the Codex CLI totally fails when I try to launch Playwright – it throws macOS seatbelt permission errors and crashes, even though installing Python packages and running `playwright install chromium` works fine. The same repo runs without a hitch on Claude, bypassing Cloudflare and starting the browser. It feels frustrating seeing one model stuck in a sandbox while the other works flawlessly, and I'm looking for any workarounds besides stepping out of Codex entirely.

Terrible 258d ago

I was used to watching Claude’s output line by line, stepping in whenever it drifted, and that let me keep the conversation on track. The new TUI just flashes a whole sentence and hides it, turning Claude into a mysterious black box. I felt blind, unable to correct mistakes in real time, and the change left me frustrated and annoyed.

Previous Oct 3
Next Oct 5

Where these reviews come from

No synthetic benchmarks. Just votes from people shipping with Claude every day.

Vote on Claude →
Primary

AI Daily Check votes

Every rating here is a vote someone cast after using Claude — via the website, the Claude Code extension, or upcoming Chrome/CLI extensions.

Context

Community signal

We cross-reference sentiment trends with curated Reddit and community posts where people share Claude wins, fails, and troubleshooting stories — so you can see what moved the needle on any given day.