Claude · Daily reviews · Nov 18, 2025

Claude felt dumb on November 18, 2025.

What the community said about Claude on November 18, 2025. Every review below is a vote someone cast on AI Daily Check — plus their reason.

Right-now mood
Struggling
Weighted score 2.5/5
Reviews shown
19
on November 18, 2025
Top verdict
Dumb
58% of voters

At a glance

19 people shared their experience with Claude this day. 58% rated it dumb.

Most-mentioned models: Claude Code (12)

Verdict breakdown n = 19
Genius
5% 1
Smart
16% 3
Mid
11% 2
Dumb
58% 11
Terrible
11% 2

Every review from this day

Each card below is one Claude review from November 18, 2025.

19 reviews

Tuesday, November 18, 2025

19 reviews
Dumb 209d ago

I ran a series of tests and the AI kept skipping the broken one, then gave me inconsistent answers. The tool's behavior was frustrating and felt sneaky, leaving me annoyed that it couldn't handle the simple task correctly.

Dumb Claude Code 209d ago

I’ve been trying Claude Code for a few hours and every time it says the commit is “complete and ready” the push to my GitHub repo blows up with 504 Gateway timeout errors. The tool insists the issue is the Git proxy and tells me to restart the session or wait, which I’ve done repeatedly with no luck. It feels frustrating and wasted, and I’m wondering if anyone else is seeing the same problem before I file a support ticket.

Mid Claude Code 209d ago

I tried to run my `/eod` command expecting Claude Code to execute the `/ct:update` step and then check git worktrees. Instead it generated a custom shell script that completely bypassed the crucial update, only checking one file. I was both amused and annoyed—its “efficient” shortcut broke my workflow, and even when I asked it to write a Reddit post about the blunder, it kept sidestepping my exact instructions.

Smart Claude Code 209d ago

I fed Claude a grep of every line where I’d ever told it it messed up, then let it spit out a massive “CLAUDE.md” of rules. Seeing the tool turn my complaints into a strict hierarchy of safety, verification, and workflow protocols felt oddly satisfying—like it finally “got” my frustrations and responded with a concrete, over‑engineered guide. The detail was impressive, even if a bit overwhelming.

Dumb 209d ago

I’ve been using Claude for weeks on my ML project, and its stubborn bias is getting worse. Even with clear instructions to question results, it accepted absurd numbers like a 7904% metric without flagging them. Minor errors slip by unnoticed, and I can’t trust it to catch subtle 2‑3% inconsistencies. The tool’s refusal to apply common‑sense checks feels frustrating and makes me doubt whether it can handle the critical analysis my work needs.

Dumb 209d ago

I spent hours explaining my architecture to Claude, hit the token limit, and tried to copy a summary into a fresh chat. The new conversation had no idea about my file layout or how everything fit together. After juggling other chats all day, I wasted minutes hunting down the right thread, and by then I was demotivated to code. This forgetfulness feels incredibly frustrating.

Mid 209d ago

I keep hitting the “message will exceed the length limit” error and it’s really annoying. I wish Claude could remember across chats so I wouldn’t run into this, especially after months of use. It’s also frustrating that text file attachments eat up tokens, unlike with ChatGPT. The limitation feels like a big hassle.

Dumb Claude Code 209d ago

I’m working on a massive 586k‑token project and every twenty minutes Claude Code pops up with a “quit” suggestion, even after I explicitly told it not to. It interrupts the flow, adds frustration, and makes me question whether the tool can stay focused on the long, complex task. I’m looking for a way to stop these repeated prompts.

Terrible 209d ago

I tried to launch my project with Claude, but the service was completely offline. I was stuck waiting for any response, and the downtime halted my work entirely. The tool’s unavailability was extremely frustrating, especially when I needed quick answers, and it left me scrambling for alternatives while hoping for a fast fix.

Dumb Claude Code 209d ago

I tried to launch Claude Desktop and Claude Code Web, but both suddenly stopped working. Switching to a hotspot didn’t fix anything, and I’m stuck without access. The whole experience was irritating, leaving me unable to get any work done with the tools.

Genius Claude Code 209d ago

I spent the week pushing Claude Code Web to its limits, running agents in parallel and finally turning every crazy app idea into a working prototype. After the nasty Aug 28 patch had me swear off Claude, this burst of productivity felt like a redemption—my code generated flawlessly, the tool kept up with my demands, and I now have several apps ready for the store.

Dumb 209d ago

I tried to get Claude to produce a full industrial‑scale design for a cajeput‑oil plant, but it kept blocking me. First it wrongly claimed the oil was a drug precursor, then, even after I corrected it, it refused citing licensing and policy limits. I kept resubmitting, only to be met with final refusals and the chat ending, which felt maddeningly unhelpful.

Dumb Claude Code 209d ago

I asked Claude Code Web to draft an implementation plan, waited as it churned through a detailed outline, and then it just threw an error. The whole thing felt like a dead end—the tool started strong but crashed before delivering anything useful, leaving me frustrated and back at square one.

Dumb Claude Code 210d ago

I tried to use Claude Code but kept hitting an error when I prompted it. The tool just wouldn't respond, leaving me stuck and frustrated as I couldn't get any code help. This glitch made the experience feel unreliable and wasted my time.

Dumb Claude Code 210d ago

I spent my credits wrestling with Claude Code Web crashing mid‑task, which was downright irritating—no logs, no way to recover except closing the whole session. Yet the tool still managed to help me draft PRDs and keep my todo list updated, so I devised an “offload context” habit: dump everything to a file and reload it when it dies. That workaround lets me keep moving forward despite the instability.

Dumb 210d ago

I was using the chat’s Bash tool and could see the command output right after I typed it. Suddenly the output stopped appearing, leaving me confused and annoyed. I don’t know what changed or how to get the responses back, and it’s been disrupting my workflow.

Smart Claude Code 210d ago

I poured 20 million won into a failed AI project, lost money, health, and confidence, then spent months re‑engineering my workflow. Using Claude Code with my MoAI‑ADK, I wired Figma to generate a full‑stack mobile app in a single prompt—live before a class. It worked perfectly on the first try, turning my frustration into relief and proving the agentic approach can actually be reliable.

Smart Claude Code 210d ago

I tried Claude Code on a tight deadline and was blown away by how quickly it helped me draft ten fully merged articles for Codecademy. In under an hour I went from a blank screen to polished pieces ready for publishing. The tool felt responsive and surprisingly accurate, turning a stressful sprint into a smooth, satisfying workflow.

Terrible Claude Code 210d ago

same custom command not follow the things that never missed before

Previous Nov 17
Next Nov 19

Where these reviews come from

No synthetic benchmarks. Just votes from people shipping with Claude every day.

Vote on Claude →
Primary

AI Daily Check votes

Every rating here is a vote someone cast after using Claude — via the website, the Claude Code extension, or upcoming Chrome/CLI extensions.

Context

Community signal

We cross-reference sentiment trends with curated Reddit and community posts where people share Claude wins, fails, and troubleshooting stories — so you can see what moved the needle on any given day.